Newyear Dualstream Day of Zeux Q4 2002 Judging Sheet:Wervyn
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Let me begin with an apology, I'm sorry there isn't more information in these
scores, but I really did have everything typed out all nice and neat with
comments and everything, when suddenly my computer crashed. As such, I'll just
be leaving a short comment for each game now, not for each judging category.
Onward!
-= 01871 =-= Trinity =------------------------------= EQUILIBRIUM =-= 191/300 =-
Gameplay: 25/65
Graphics: 45/50
Plot: 30/50
Theme: 25/45
Innovation: 35/40
Discretion: 10/15
Music: 20/30
Sound: 01/05
Subtotal: 191/300
Comment: Most of the score hits come from the game being unfinished. Nice
game with a disappointing "end".
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 08975 =-= Final Fantasy 30 =--------------------= DISQUALIFIED =-= 000/300 =-
Comment: Not only is this a joke entry, but it's a joke entry that was
submitted LAST YEAR. I have no desire to actually rate this game.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 26513 =-= Medicine Run =------------------------= DISQUALIFIED =-= 000/300 =-
Gameplay: 05/65
Graphics: 10/50
Plot: 05/50
Theme: 15/45
Innovation: 00/40
Discretion: 05/15
Music: 01/30
Sound: 01/05
Subtotal: 042/300 (DQ)
Comment: Use of the Xenogenesis title screen immediately earmarks this one
for the garbage.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 27523 =-= FIND TEH MEDICINE FOR OLD MAN =-----------= MEDICINE =-= 028/300 =-
Gameplay: 10/65
Graphics: 02/50
Plot: 00/50
Theme: 05/45
Innovation: 05/40
Discretion: 05/15
Music: 01/30
Sound: 00/05
Subtotal: 028/300
Comment: Eck, who submits stuff like this. There's basically nothing good
I can say about it.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 30275 =-= FAILED =------------------------------= DISQUALIFIED =-= 000/300 =-
Comment: No actual game, and what is there bears apparently no relevence to
either theme. I can't give this any rating.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 32335 =-= Panacea =---------------------------------= MEDICINE =-= 195/300 =-
Gameplay: 45/65
Graphics: 32/50
Plot: 25/50
Theme: 25/45
Innovation: 30/40
Discretion: 15/15
Music: 20/30
Sound: 03/05
Subtotal: 195/300
Comment: Nice game, plot is a bit thin, medicine is less of a theme and
more just a plot device.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 37701 =-= Larry the Junkie =------------------------= MEDICINE =-= 117/300 =-
Gameplay: 15/65
Graphics: 35/50
Plot: 10/50
Theme: 10/45
Innovation: 20/40
Discretion: 10/15
Music: 15/30
Sound: 02/05
Subtotal: 117/300
Comment: This game didn't really work, pure and simple. I couldn't do
anything, and had to make judgments based on looking over the file
itself.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 41192 =-= Revival =-----------------------------= DISQUALIFIED =-= 000/300 =-
Gameplay: 40/65
Graphics: 20/50
Plot: 25/50
Theme: 30/45
Innovation: 15/40
Discretion: 15/15
Music: 01/30
Sound: 01/05
Subtotal: 147/300 (DQ)
Comment: A real pity Clowd didn't think to read the rules before submitting
this.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 47506 =-= Crisis in Stuffyou City =-----------------= MEDICINE =-= 184/300 =-
Gameplay: 45/65
Graphics: 40/50
Plot: 15/50
Theme: 30/45
Innovation: 30/40
Discretion: 00/15
Music: 20/30
Sound: 04/05
Subtotal: 184/300
Comment: What could have possibly made twenty minutes of repetitive cinemas
seem like a good idea? Did you think you were being funny, or
were you actually trying for excessively lame?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 48493 =-= Flame of Revok =----------------------= DISQUALIFIED =-= 000/300 =-
Gameplay: 50/65
Graphics: 35/50
Plot: 10/50
Theme: 02/45
Innovation: 30/40
Discretion: 10/15
Music: 20/30
Sound: 03/05
Subtotal: 160/300 (DQ)
Comment: The gameplay worked pretty well once you figured it out (albeit
the instructions in the beginning told you to do the OPPOSITE of
what worked). However, little plot is here, and I don't see how
this has any relation to the theme whatsoever, beyond the word
equilibrium in the intro. Is that Chrono Trigger I hear?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 51929 =-= The Herb of Tridia =----------------------= MEDICINE =-= 133/300 =-
Gameplay: 20/65
Graphics: 25/50
Plot: 25/50
Theme: 20/45
Innovation: 15/40
Discretion: 10/15
Music: 15/30
Sound: 03/05
Subtotal: 133/300
Comment: First part of the game is too dark to see, impossible to fight
enemies or see walls to tell where to go. Half-hearted plot, and
a cop out on the boss fight make this a pretty mediocre game.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-= 64966 =-= All in a Day's Work =---------------------= MEDICINE =-= 162/300 =-
Gameplay: 35/65
Graphics: 40/50
Plot: 20/50
Theme: 15/45
Innovation: 35/40
Discretion: 15/15
Music: 01/30
Sound: 01/05
Subtotal: 162/300
Comment: Cool engines, gameplay mechanics, but the whole thing feels more
like an excuse to show off some cool programming stuff than an
actual game under the theme.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Final Scores:
Before Weight Ranking:
Placement Team Game Name Score (/300)
1. 1. 32335 Panacea 195
2. 2. 01871 Trinity 191
4. 3. 47506 Crisis in Stuffyou City 184
3. 4. 64966 All in a Day's Work 162
5. 5. 51929 The Herb of Tridia 133
6. 6. 37701 Larry the Junkie 117
7. 7. 27523 FIND TEH MEDICINE FOR OLD MAN 28
Mine^ ^Absolute
------------------------------------------------------------
After Weight Ranking:
Placement Team Game Name Score (/400)
1. 32335 Panacea 295 (+100)
2. 01871 Trinity 274 (+ 83)
3. 47506 Crisis in Stuffyou City 234 (+ 50)
4. 64966 All in a Day's Work 229 (+ 67)
5. 51929 The Herb of Tridia 166 (+ 33)
6. 37701 Larry the Junkie 134 (+ 17)
7. 27523 FIND TEH MEDICINE FOR OLD MAN 28 (+ 00)
------------------------------------------------------------
* Note: As explained to me by Exo, the weight ranking is based on the judge's
own subjective opinion of the game, not their absolute score before
weighting. Scores have been readjusted accordingly. If this is not
satisfactory, there is enough information here to recalculate them
according to whatever is the correct standard.
Disqualified Entries:
Placement Team Game Name Score (/300)
1. 48493 Flame of Revok 160
2. 41192 Revival 144
3. 26513 Medicine Run 42
4. 08975 Final Fantasy 30 0
4. 30275 FAILED 0
------------------------------------------------------------
Winners by Category
Medicine
Placement Team Game Name Score (/400)
1. 32335 Panacea 295
2. 47506 Crisis in Stuffyou City 234
3. 64966 All in a Day's Work 229
4. 51929 The Herb of Tridia 166
5. 37701 Larry the Junkie 134
6. 27523 FIND TEH MEDICINE FOR OLD MAN 28
Equilibrium
Placement Team Game Name Score (/400)
1. 01871 Trinity 274
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------